| Species | Weight | Location | Date | Angler |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bass, largemouth | 10lbs 14oz | Menantico Sand Wash Pond | 1980 | Robert Eisele |
| Bass, rock | 1lb 5oz | Saddle River | 1982 | Eric Avogardo |
| Bass, smallmouth | 7lbs 2oz | Round Valley Reservoir | 1990 | Carol Marciniak |
| Bluegill | 3lbs | Farm Pond in Pennington | 1990 | Dom Santarelli |
| Bowfin | 11lbs 8.5oz | Mantua Creek | 2017 | Pierce Dopkin |
| Bullhead, brown | 4lbs 8oz | Lake of the Woods (Fort Dix) | 1997 | Gary Schmidt |
| Carp, Common | 47lbs | South Branch of Raritan River | 1995 | Billy Friedman |
| Carp, grass | 55lbs 8oz | Curlis Lake | 2011 | James Dempsey, Jr. |
| Catfish, channel | 33lbs 3oz | Lake Hopatcong | 1978 | Howard Hudson |
| Catfish, white | 14lbs 4oz | Dallenbach Pond | 2004 | Timothy Jasko |
| Crappie, black | 4lbs 8oz | Pompton Lake | 1996 | Andy Tintle |
| Crappie, white | 3lbs 11oz | Mercer Lake | 2009 | William Lewis |
| Eel, American | 6lbs 13oz | Round Valley Reservoir | 2005 | David J. Payne |
| Muskellunge | 42lbs 13oz | Monksville Reservoir | 1997 | Bob Neals |
| Muskie, tiger | 29lbs | Delaware River | 1990 | Larry Migliarese |
| Perch, white | 3lbs 1oz | Forest Hill Park Lake | 1989 | Edward Tango |
| Perch, yellow | 2lbs 6oz | Holiday Lake | 1989 | Gene Engels |
| Pickerel, chain | 9lbs 3oz | Lower Aetna Lake | 1957 | Frank McGovern |
| Pickerel, redfin | 1lb 13oz | Lake Assunpink | 1982 | Gerald Humphrey |
| Pike, Northern | 30lbs 8.5oz | Pompton Lake | 2009 | John Viglione |
| Salmon (landlocked) | 8lbs 10oz | Merrill Creek Reservoir | 2021 | Joe Satkowski |
| Shad, American | 11lbs 1oz | Delaware River | 1984 | Charles Mower |
| Striped Bass | 51lbs | Great Egg Harbor River | 2002 | John Christian |
| Striped Bass, hybrid | 16lbs 10oz | Monksville Reservoir | 2022 | John Vayda |
| Sunfish, pumpkinseed | 1lb 8oz | Farm Pond | 1987 | Daryl Donalson |
| Trout, brook | 7lbs 3oz | Rockaway River | 1995 | Andrew DuJack |
| Trout, brown | 21lbs 6oz | Round Valley Reservoir | 1995 | Lenny Saccente |
| Trout, lake | 32lbs 8oz | Round Valley Reservoir | 2002 | Gregory Young |
| Trout, rainbow | 13lbs | Lake Hopatcong | 1988 | Gene Rutkoski |
| Walleye | 13lbs 9oz | Delaware River | 1993 | George Fundell |
Non-Hook and Line Records
| Species | Weight | Location | Date | Angler |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carp, Common (archery) | 45lbs 6oz | Greenwood Lake | 2014 | Adam Faatz |
| Carp, grass (archery) | 76lbs 11oz | Delaware River | 2020 | Daniel E. Sandorff |